Dairy Farm's FY19 core net profit (-10.4% y-o-y) was in-line at 100.2% of our forecast (US$320.1m), but below at 94% of consensus (US$341.5m).
HK retail remains weak. Covid-19 outbreak also clouds near-term convenience and restaurant earnings, in our view. We cut FY20-21F EPS.
We reiterate REDUCE, with a lower Target Price of US$4.38, now at 17x, the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) level in FY08-09, as we roll forward to FY21F EPS.
FY19 Core EBIT Down 13.6% Y-o-y; FY19 Net Profit Down 10.4% Y-o-y
Dairy Farm (SGX:D01)'s FY19 core group EBIT of US$436.8m was down 13.6% y-o-y as three out of DFI’s four formats weakened.
We estimate food EBIT grew (+50% y-o-y) on the back of an improvement in profitability for SEA with the ongoing strategic restructuring.
We estimate convenience store segment EBIT fell 6.2% y-o-y due to pre-opening costs for new 7- Eleven stores in Guangdong.
We estimate health and beauty (H&B) segment saw protest pressures bring 2H19 EBIT down 29% y-o-y; ultimately resulting in FY19 falling 10.1% y-o-y.
We estimate home & furnishings (H&F) segment EBIT fell (-33.2% y-o-y) on higher pre-operating costs for upcoming stores. This led to FY19 core net profit falling 10.4% y-o-y.
The silver lining was an unchanged final DPS of 14.50 US$cts, which took full-year DPS to 21 US$cts – in line with expectations.
Restated Yonghui and RRHI Contributions
While FY19 associate earnings rose 10% y-o-y, this was below our expectations due to restated food segment contribution (Yonghui and RRHI) - likely due to IFRS 16 adjustments for both entities. Hence, while we expected shrinking restaurant contribution (-21.4% y-o-y), the lower contribution from the food segment was a negative surprise.
Covid-19 Outlook Clouds FY20F Prospects
Several HK retail-linked datapoints remained weak in Jan-20. The Covid-19 outbreak adds to Dairy Farm’s near-term risk, in our view. In 2003 during the SARS outbreak, restaurant earnings fell 30% y-o-y, while convenience store EBIT shrank 10% y-o-y as footfall fell in both formats.
We believe Covid-19 will continue to impact DFI's North Asia EBIT and associate earnings (Maxim’s); hence, we cut FY20-21F EPS by 13.1%/10.9% (Fig 8).
Reiterate Reduce, Still Clouded by Near-term Uncertainties
We are heartened that Dairy Farm’s multi-year transformation programme is bearing fruit in its SEA food business; however, the near-term uncertainties in HK (Dairy Farm’s main earnings contributor over the past three years) are still too large to ignore.
We think the stock could trade down to GFC levels in FY08-09, hence we ascribe a lower PER of 17x (c. -1.5 s.d. to its 13-year average), now based on FY21F EPS. This lowers our Target Price to US$4.38 (US$5.40 previously).
Upside risks are swifter-than-expected resolution to HK protests, better sales growth and margin expansion.
Potential de-rating catalysts include continued HK protests, weaker sales/margins and cuts in dividend payouts.
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....