There were no surprises from SingTel's results call. While operational improvements should continue to dictate and drive EBITDA prospects, group revenue should remain under pressure due to competitive headwinds and Optus engineering a difficult revenue recovery. We pare our FY14/15 forecasts after tweaking our AUD/SGD assumption. This pulls down our SOP-based FV to SGD3.55 (from SGD3.70) which has also incorporated the latest valuations of its listed OpCos.
- Scores in mobile but competitive pressure in IPTV and broadband rises. SingTel gained further market share in mobile and IPTV segments, thanks to the aggressive bundling of its services under mioHome and mio-Plans. However, its share of IPTV and the broadband market is likely to come under pressure going forward, due to the cross carriage agreement with StarHub (STH SP, NEUTRAL, FV: SGD4.60) and heavy competition in the fixed broadband space. The company intends to defend its premium position in the fibre market, which we believe should ease concerns of a potentially unproductive price war.
- Optus set to excel. After executing a massive transformation plan to rebrand its service and the overhaul of its distribution model over the past 12-18 months, Optus appears confident of gaining revenue and EBITDA share in the quarters ahead. However, we think that revenue recovery will take time since the mobile market in Australia is still reeling from lower/ device subsidies and falling interconnection rates amid a shrinking subscriber base.
- AUD strengthens. The AUD has appreciated 1.3% against the SGD YTD, after shedding 10% in 2013. This would have a positive impact on Optus‟ translated revenue and EBITDA going into FY15.
- NEUTRAL maintained. We lower our FY14/15 forecasts by 2-3% after adjusting our AUD forex assumption. Incorporating the latest mark-tomarket valuations of its listed OpCos and the group‟s latest net debt position, our SOP-based FV is revised to SGD3.55 (from SGD3.70). SingTel remains a NEUTRAL due to the lack of meaningful rerating catalysts. Our top pick for exposure to Singapore telecoms is M1 (M1 SP, BUY, SD3.65).
Key Takeaways From 9MFY14 Results Conference Call
SingTel‟s results conference call was hosted by its senior management team, comprising of Group CEO Chua Sock Koong, Group CFO Jeann Low, CEO of group consumer (GC) Paul O‟ Sullivan, CEO of group enterprise (GE) Bill Chang and CEO of group digital life (GDL), Allen Lew. There were no surprises, with questions centred mainly on its digital business, competitive position and Optus‟ outlook.
Singapore
Continues to gain market share in mobile and IPTV
SingTel gained further market share in mobile and IPTV, thanks to the aggressive bundling of its services under the mio-Home and mio-Plans. Its share of the IPTV and broadband market is, however, likely to be pressured by the cross carriage of the Barclays Premier League (BPL) on StarHub and the heavy competition in the fixed broadband space. SingTel‟s share of mobile revenue inched higher to 52.6% in 3QFY14 from 52.3% in 2QFY14 while that of IPTV widened to 44% from 43.8% over the same period.
Tiered data subscribers now 53% of its postpaid base
Mobile revenue ticked up 2% q-o-q and 5.2% y-o-y in 3QFY13 due to: i) a higher proportion of subscribers on tiered data plans, ii) seasonally higher roaming revenue,and iii) increased data usage. This is above the industry‟s 1.8% q-o-q and 3% y-o-y revenue growth, given SingTel‟s larger subscriber base and higher roaming revenue mix vs its peers. While the number of postpaid subscribers on tiered 4G data plans spiked up to 53% in 3QFY14 from 37% in the preceding quarter (excluding data only SIMs), postpaid ARPU fell 1% q-o-q and 4% y-o-y. Management attributed this to the dilution from low-ARPU data-only SIMs.
Not devaluing its premium position on fibre
SingTel said it intends to maintain its premium position in the fibre market and will not compete on price. Like StarHub, it will continue to actively push for migration from asymmetric digital subscriber line (ADSL) to fibre and for the take-up of triple play services to boost ARPU. We believe a price war would be counter intuitive and unproductive as this would make it more difficult to monetise data, with telcos already aggressively bundling services. SingTel‟s stance on pricing should be well-received by StarHub as the latter has been closely monitoring its rival‟s next move, coming on the heels of MyRepublic (an internet service provider)‟s 1Gbps fibre plan which is being offered at SGD49.90/month for a limited period. Compared to the standalone fibre service offered by MyRepublic, SingTel‟s and StarHub‟s fibre plans are offered alongside mobile, voice and IPTV services which may be bundled.
Australia
Optus set to excel
Having executed a massive transformation plan to rebrand its services, which included the overhaul of its distribution channels over the past 12-18 months, Optus appears confident of gaining revenue and EBITDA share in the ensuing quarters. It has started to see the benefits of the initiatives filtering through via the improvement in the net promoter score (NPS), a metric used to track customer experience and brand perception, and lower subscriber churn. The notable measures undertaken in the past quarter include: i) the conversion of 120 franchised stores into companyowned retail stores, ii) the U900 3G migration expanded in building coverage to 94% of the population via the upgrade of 4400 sites nationwide, and iii) the expansion of 4G metro coverage. We think revenue recovery will take time given that the mobile market in Australia is still reeling from lower device/removal of subsidies and the fall in interconnection rates amid a shrinking subscriber base.
Others
SGD500m investments in GDL to date
SingTel has spent SGD500m of the SGD2bn set aside for investments in adjacent industries. Management emphasised the need to ramp up customer engagement in driving revenue growth to maximise operating leverage. For that, it continues to adopt a longer term view on the start-up businesses.
Forecast & Guidance
SingTel has recalibrated its guidance to take into account the currency trends YTD, the greater visibility on capex and the latest business outlook.
- It expects group consumer (GC) revenue to exhibit a "low double digit decline‟ from "high single digit decline‟ previously. GC revenue fell 10.1% in 9MFY14, dragged down by the 13.3% decline at Optus arising from the 10% depreciation of the AUD/SGD.
- Group enterprise (GE) revenue guidance has been revised to "low single digit decline from "stable‟ previously. SingTel cited steepening competition and the generally more cautious business outlook behind the new guidance.
- It expects group capex to trend lower to SGD2.2bn from SGD2.5bn from delayed spending and the weaker AUD.
- We lower our FY14/15 forecasts by 2-3%, after adjusting our FX assumptions, which have factored in a more aggressive strengthening of the AUD previously to be closer to the average AUD/SGD rate for 9MFY14 of SGD1.18/AUD.
Risks
The key risks to our forecasts are: i) a stronger SGD, ii) rising competition in key markets, and iii) higher-than-expected subscriber acquisition costs.
Valuation & Recommendation
Maintain NEUTRAL. Our SOP-based FV is lowered to SGD3.55 (from SGD3.70), after incorporating the market valuations of the group‟s listed OpCos, including our recent downward revision in our fair value for ADVANC (ADVANC TB, BUY, FV: THB248), as well as adjusting for the latest net debt level. SingTel remains a NEUTRAL due to the lack of rerating catalysts and the competitive/structural headwinds in Singapore and Australia. Our Top Pick for the Singapore telecoms sector remains M1 (BUY, FV: SGD3.65)
Financial Exhibits
SWOT Analysis
Company Profile
SingTel is the largest telecommunications operator in the Asia Pacific region with class-leading mobile assets in Singapore, Australia, India, Indonesia, Thailand and Philippines, amongst others
Recommendation Chart