UOB's 3QFY13 net profit of SGD730m (+3% y-o-y; -7% q-o-q) was in line with our and consensus estimates. While the results were buoyed by lumpy gains from sale of investments, there were also decent underlying trends such as stable NIMs (despite lower LDR) and continued improvement in asset quality. Maintain BUY call and SGD24.50 FV (from SGD24.40), on rolling forward ourvaluations.
- 3QFY13 results in line. UOB's 3QFY13 net profit of SGD730m (+3% yo-y; -7% q-o-q) was in line with our and consensus expectations. This was despite its 9MFY13 net profit of SGD2.2bn (+6% y-o-y) accounting for 78% of our and consensus full-year estimates. We expect a softer 4Q on account of lower lumpy gains from sale of investments.
- Result highlights.3QFY13's positives include: i) steady growth in net interest income (+8% y-o-y; +3% q-o-q); ii) stable NIM q-o-q despite deposit growth outpacing loan growth (group loan-to-deposit ratio (LDR) declined to 88.3% from 89.9% a quarter ago); iii) lower overheads (-2% q-o-q) and hence, cost-to-income ratio (CIR) dippedq-o-q to 43% from 44.2% in 2QFY13; iv) the quarterly fee income of SGD407m was above the earlier guidance for a normalised run rate of SGD350mSGD400m/quarter; and v) improving asset quality and lower loan allowances. However, excluding the lumpy SGD40m gain from disposal of Pan Pacific, non-interest income would have been8% lower q-o-q due to weaker fee and trading and investment income. Loan growth also slowed down further to +2% q-o-q vs 2QFY13's +3% q-o-q.
- Briefing highlights. Management sees NIMs drifting sideways and expects full-year loan growth to meet its low to mid-teens guidance. For 2014, UOB is guiding for loan growth of about high-single to low-double digits. Housing loans growth, however, is expected to slow down given that loan approvals are currently 30-40% lower than a year ago. Management remains comfortable with asset quality and did not rule out potential M&As if the pricing is right and there are synergies to reap.
- Forecasts.No changes to our earnings forecasts.
- Investment case.We tweak our FV to SGD24.50 (from SGD24.40) after rolling forward our valuation base year to end-2014 (from June 2014), partly offset by a revised target P/BV multiple of 1.45x (from 1.5x). Maintain BUY.
3QFY13 results review
UOB's 3QFY13 net profit of SGD730m (+3% y-o-y; -7% q-o-q) was in line with our and consensus expectations, despite 9MFY13 net profit of SGD2.2bn (+6% y-o-y) accounting for 78% of our and consensus full-year estimates. We expect a softer 4Q on account of lower lumpy gains from sale of investments.
3QFY13 net interest income was decent, up 3% q-o-q and 8% y-o-y with the rise driven by higher asset volume. NIM was stable q-o-qas the pressure on asset yield (-3bps q-o-q) was offset by lower funding cost (-3bpsq-o-q). UOB's ability to hold NIM stable was all the more impressive considering that deposit growth had outpaced loan growth during the quarter (see below). Averageloan yield fell 6bps q-o-q, which management attributed to a combination of adverse forex translation impact and stronger growth in lower-yielding corporate loans. The lower loan yield, however, was partly offset by stronger yield on its securities portfolio (+7bps q-o-q) thanks to higher yields from its investments in government securities regionally. Y-o-Y, 3QFY13 NIM was down 13bps as asset yield compressed by 26bps y-o-y due to the low interest rate environment.
Looking ahead, management expects NIMs to hover around current levels. UOB has been repricing up its new mortgages and this has started to have an impact in stabilising yields from the consumer segment. However, UOB is not lengthening the duration of its securities portfolio just yet and for NIMs to rise, short term rates will need to go up as well.
3QFY13 non-interest income softened 2% q-o-q with fee income 7% lower q-o-q at SGD407m. Nevertheless, this was still above the normalised quarterly run rate of SGD350-SGD400m that management guided previously. Trading and investment income, however, was up 20% q-o-q as UOB booked in a SGD40m gain from the disposal of its investment in Pan Pacific. Excluding this, trading and investment income would have been down 11% q-o-q due to tougher market conditions stemming from potential Quantitative Easing (QE) tapering by the US Fed. Y-o-Y, non-interest income was down 11% as trading and investment income slipped 41% y-o-y, cushioned by stronger fee income (+9% y-o-y). Overall, 3QFY13 operating
income rose 1% q-o-q (flat y-o-y) but non-interest income contribution decreased to 37.1% vs. 2QFY13: 38.2%; 3QFY12: 41.6%.
Overheads were generally under control, down 2% q-o-q but up 4% y-o-y. Consequently, 3QFY13 cost-to-income ratio (CIR) improved q-o-q to 43% as compared to around 44.2% in 2QFY13 but was higher than the 41.3% in 3QFY12. As a result, 3QFY13 pre-provision operating profit rose 4% q-o-q but was down 3% y-oy. Despite the stronger pre-provision profit, 3QFY13 net profit was lower q-o-q due to: 1) impairment charge of SGD29m on other assets vs. impairment writeback of SGD52m in 2QFY13. Loan allowances, however, were lower at SGD56m (2QFY13: SGD127m); and 2) weaker contribution from associates and joint ventures due to lumpy investment gains recognised in 2QFY13. Y-o-Y, it was the reverse with net profit up 3% despite the weaker pre-provision profit due to lower impairment on loans and other assets (-30% y-o-y) and higher contribution from associates (+148% y-o-y). As expected, gross loan growth momentum eased further to +2% q-o-q (+16% y-o-y) vs. 2QFY13: +3% q-o-q (+15% y-o-y). Sequential growth was driven by Singapore (+2% q-o-q), Greater China (+7% q-o-q, mainly due to loans to Hong Kong corporates) and Others (+6% q-o-q). South East Asiamarkets such as Malaysia and Indonesia saw loan base (in SGD) contract 1-8% q-o-q mainly due to adverse foreign currency translation effects. For the full-year, management retained their guidance of low to mid-teens loans growth.
Meanwhile, total customer deposits growth outpaced loans growth, up 4% q-o-q (+13% y-o-y) led by fixed (+7% q-o-q/+13% y-o-y) and other (+7% q-o-q and y-o-y) deposits. By currency, q-o-q growth was driven by SGD and USD deposits. Consequently, group loan to deposit ratio (LDR) declined to 88.3% from 89.9% as at end-2QFY13 (end-3QFY12: 86%) while SGD and USD LDR were 91.7% (end-2QFY13: 95.1%) and 84.4% (end-2QFY13: 89.1%) respectively. Current account and savings account (CASA) deposits stayed flat q-o-q (+13% y-o-y) and hence, CASA ratio declined to 40.5% from 42.2% as at end-June '13 (end-3QFY12: 40.5%). UOB was the only banking group that reported an improvement in asset quality, with absolute gross NPL and NPA down 2% (-16% y-o-y) and 3% q-o-q (-17% y-o-y) respectively. Part of the improvement was attributed by UOB to currency effects on the regional subsidiaries. Thus, the gross NPL ratio improved by 5bps q-o-q to 1.19% while cumulative allowances were 141% of total NPAs, up from 137% as at 30 June 2013. Management said there were no signs of systemic asset quality issues at this juncture.
Finally, UOB disclosed Basel III CET-1/Tier 1/Total capital ratios of 12.9%/12.9%/16.3% respectively as at end-Sept 2013. This were down about 70-90bps as compared to end-June 2013 with the decline mainly due to higher risk weighted assets (+5% q-o-q vs. total assets that stayed flat q-o-q). Management attributed the rise in RWA to continued loan growthand a one-time realignment for the computation of market risk.
Other briefing highlights
Looking ahead to 2014, UOB sees loan growth of around high single to low double digit (vs our 6% assumption). Growth in housing loans, however, is expected to slow down, especially in 2H2014, with loan approvals currently down by 30-40% from a year ago. The drop appears to be sharper than peers, who both reported a decline of 30% y-o-y. Management remains comfortable with the Thai and Indonesian operations, citing comfortable funding positions and asset quality trends. For Thailand, UOB is targeting to penetrate the supply chain of multi-national companies and to grow its business outside of Bangkok. For Indonesia, management said that the group will maintain its deposit pricing discipline and hence, will pace loan growth accordingly.
Finally, while UOB remains open to potential M&A activities, management stressed this will only be done at the right price and if there are synergies to be reaped. While Hong Kong is an attractive market to capture China flows, management highlighted that this will need to be weighed against the steps China is taking to liberalise its economy (eg Shanghai Free Trade Zone).
Risks
The risks include: i) slower-than-expected loan growth, ii) weaker-than-expected NIMs, iii) weaker-than-expected capital market activities, iv) a deterioration in asset quality, and v) adverse impact from rising bond yields on the securities portfolio.
Forecasts
No changes to our earnings forecasts.
Valuation and recommendation
We tweak up our FV to SGD24.50 (from SGD24.40), after rolling forward our valuation base year to end-2014 (previously June 2014) and reducing our target P/BV multiple to 1.45x from 1.5x. Our new 1.45x P/BV, which is a similar target P/BV multiple that we ascribe to OCBC (OCBC SP, NEUTRAL, FV: SGD10.90), is at a slight discount to the stock's five-year average P/BV multiple of 1.5x, to reflect the potential impact ahead from the slowdown in mortgage approvals, which appears to be sharper than peers. On balance, UOB did manage to report some decent underlying trends this quarter, such as stable NIMsand further improvement in asset quality. Over the longer term, we think the group is well-positioned to benefit from Asean's rise as a new growth haven. Reiterate BUY.
Company Profile
UOB is the second-largest Singapore bank by loan. It also has significant operations in Malaysia, Thailand & Indonesia.