DBS' 3QFY13 results met our and consensus expectations. Similar to the previous quarter, the q-o-q drop in net profit was mainly due to weaker non-interest income. Going forward, DBS expects to keep its net profit growth next year, driven by continued loan growth while overheads and loan allowances remain contained. Maintain BUY, with a revised SGD19.40 FV (from SGD18.70), after a roll-forward in valuations.
- 3QFY13 results in line. DBS' 3QFY13 net profit of SGD862m (+1% y-oy; -3% q-o-q) was in line with our and consensus expectations. Its 9MFY13 net profit stood at SGD2.7bn (+4% y-o-y), accounting for 75% of our and consensus full-year net profit estimates.
- Results highlights. The q-o-q net profit drop was mainly due to weaker non-interest income (-20% q-o-q), not too surprising given the tougher market conditions which led to a 44% q-o-q decline in trading income, while market-related fee income slipped 26% q-o-q. On a more positive note, net interest income growth was decent (+2% q-o-q), supported by continued loan growth while NIM was marginally lower at 1.6% (-2bps qo-q). Overheads were contained (-4% q-o-q) while loan allowances were lower (-38% q-o-q). 9M net profit rose 4% y-o-y on the back of: i) loan volume-driven net interest income growth of 3% y-o-y, ii) broad-based growth in non-interest income (+26% y-o-y), and iii) positive jaws (9M cost-to-income ratio (CIR) was 42.6% vs 9MFY12: 43.8%). These, however, were partly offset by higher loan allowances (+104% y-o-y) as specific allowances started to normalise and general allowances climbed due to strong loan growth.
- Briefing highlights. DBS projects mid-single digit bottomline growth for 2014, similar to 2013 level, mainly driven by loan growth of 8-10%, operating expenses staying contained (ie jaws positive), and stable loan provisioning. We forecast FY14 net profit growth of 7% y-o-y, similar to FY13 growth estimate. DBS is still keen on growing its private banking,but would only be interested in private banks with Asia-centric portfolios.
- Forecasts. Our earnings forecasts are unchanged.
- Investment case. We raise our FV to SGD19.40 from SGD18.70, after rolling forward our valuation base year to end-2014 (previously June 2014). There are no changes to our target P/BV multiple of 1.3x. We continue to like DBS for its stronger earnings growth prospects relative to peers, while its valuations are at a discount to peers.
3QFY13 results review
DBS' 3QFY13 net profit of SGD862m (+1% y-o-y; -3% q-o-q) was in line with our and consensus expectations. Its 9MFY13 net profit stood at SGD2.7bn (+4% y-o-y), accounting for 75% of our and consensus full-year net profit estimates. 3QFY13 net interest income (+6% y-o-y; +2% q-o-q) continued to be well-supported by the expansion in loan base, up 19% y-o-y and 3% q-o-q. NIM was marginally lower q-o-q at 1.6% (-2bps q-o-q; -7bps y-o-y), but generally still within management's expectation. During the quarter, DBS had taken steps such as hedging, paring down of its longer-end book and bulking up its USD liquidity, in anticipation that the US Fed would start to taper quantitative easing (QE). As such, average asset yield fell 4bps q-o-q, with yields on investment securities down 11bps q-o-q (+41bps y-o-y). Loan yields were also lower (-4bps q-o-q; -20bps y-o-y) due to lower corporate and trade loan spreads. In mitigation, average funding cost was lower by 2bps q-o-q (-9bps y-o-y), as the build-up in USD deposits allowed DBS to shed costlier SGD fixed deposits.
Non-interest income, not surprisingly, shrank 20% q-o-q. This was a reflection of the tougher market conditions during the quarter, which led to a 44% q-o-q drop in trading income while market-related fee income slipped 26% q-o-q. Y-o-y, however, 3QFY13 non-interest income improved 11% and fee income grew 19% on higher contributions from trade and transaction services and wealth management, while trading income rose 13% due to higher trading gains and higher treasury customer flows. With the q-o-q drop, non-interest income contribution declined to 34.6% from 40.1% in 2QFY13, but still higher than the 33.5% recorded in 3QFY12. 3QFY13 operating income growth also largely mirrored the growth in non-interest income, ie down 7% q-o-q but up 7% y-o-y.
Overheads remained well-contained, down 4% q-o-q (a broad-based decline) while the y-o-y rise was capped at 5%. Thus, y-o-y, DBS still enjoyed positive jaws, as operating income growth outpaced growth in expenses, leading to CIR improving y-oy to 44.1% (3QFY12: 45%). Q-o-q, CIR was higher vis-à-vis 2QFY13's CIR of 42.7%, but this was expected due to softer operating income levels.
3QFY13 loan allowances fell 38% q-o-q on the back of lower specific and general allowances, but surged 175% y-o-y due to a combination of normalising specific allowance charge-offs from the exceptionally low levels last year and strong loan growth (higher general allowances). Specific allowances/loans stood at 15bps of loans (3QFY12: 7bps; 2QFY13: 22bps). With higher loan allowances, y-o-y net profit growth stood at a more muted 1%, while net profit fell 3% q-o-q.
3QFY13 gross loan growth continued to moderate to +3% q-o-q (+19% y-o-y, due to the base effect) vs 2QFY13's +5% q-o-q (+14% y-o-y), although this was expected. Q-o-q growth was largely driven by trade loans and secured consumer loans. Annualised gross loan growth was 20%. DBS guided for 4QFY13 loan growth of 2%, which would bring 2013 loan growth to the mid-high teens mark. Looking ahead to 2014, management guided for loan growth of 8-10%, with the slowdown partly due to a moderation in mortgages. The property cooling measures have resulted in new mortgage bookings slipping 30% from a year ago. Meanwhile, total customer deposits broadly kept pace with loan growth, up 3% q-o-q (+13% y-o-y) and hence, group loan-to-deposit ratio (LDR) was broadly stable at 89.5% (2QFY13: 89.8%; 3QFY12: 85.2%). however, there was a shift in deposit composition in the currency mix, with USD deposits rising 24% q-o-q (+28% y-o-y) while SGD deposits fell 2% q-o-q (+5% y-o-y), as DBS sought to build up USD liquidity. Consequently, USD LDR declined q -o-q to 133% from 161% at end-2QFY13, while SGD LDR inched up to 72.5% from 70.5% at end-June 2013. Going forward, management believes the QE tapering will likely be pushed back to 2014.
Thus, DBS would be willing to allow its USD LDR to rise back up in the near term and is comfortable with a 150-160% LDR. Current account, savings account (CASA) growth was slower at 2% q-o-q (+10% y-o-y), resulting in group CASA ratio declining to 58.4% from 59.4% at end-June (end-3QFY12: 59.7%). Absolute gross non-performing asset (NPA) rose 3% q-o-q (+8 y-o-y) on the back of higher new NPAs during the quarter of SGD291m (2QFY13: SGD242m; 3QFY12: SGD50m). Nevertheless, management thinks new NPA formation is likely to level off at the SGD250m-300m range going forward. Except for the mid-cap portfolio in India, asset quality generally remained benign. The gross NPL ratio was unchanged q-o-q at 1.2%, and down from 1.29% a year ago. NPA coverage stood at 136% (2QFY13: 141%; 3QFY12: 134%).
Finally, Basel III CET-1/Tier 1/total capital ratios rose 40-50bps q-o-q to 13.3%/13.3%/15.9% respectively. This was chiefly due to lower risk-weighted assets following updates to its internal credit ratings. Thus, both total credit risk and RWA declined by 3% q-o-q, while RWA/total assets dropped by 400bps q-o-q to 58.8%. Other briefing highlights Looking ahead to 2014, DBS thinks Europe may surprise on the upside but the US economy may pan out to be weaker than expected. All in, management estimates mid-single digit bottomline growth for 2014, similar to 2013 level. This would be driven by loan growth of 8-10%, operating expense staying contained (ie jaws positive) and stable loan provisioning. We forecast FY14 net profit growth of 7% y-oy, similar to our FY13 growth estimate. Finally, DBS is still keen on growing its private banking but would only be interested in private banks with Asia-centric portfolios.
Risks
The risks include: i) slower-than-expected loan growth, ii) weaker-than-expected NIMs, iii) weaker-than-expected capital market activities, iv) a deterioration in asset quality, and v) the adverse impact from rising bond yields on the securities portfolio.
Forecasts
No changes to our earnings forecasts.
Valuation and recommendation
We raise our FV to SGD19.40 (from SGD18.70) after we roll forward our valuation base year to end-2014 (previously June 2014). There are no changes to our target P/BV multiple of 1.3x. We continue to like DBS for its stronger earnings growth
relative to peers while valuations are relatively cheaper as well. The bank is also less vulnerable to policy changes on the property market sector, given its relatively smaller exposure to the segment. Thus, we are keeping our BUY call on the stock.
Company Profile
DBS is the largest Singapore bank by assets. It also has significant operations in HK.
Recommendation Chart