OCBC's 3QFY13 results were in line with our and consensus expectations, with net profit rebounding strongly q-o-q to SGD759m (+27% q-o-q; +5% y-o-y) owing to mark-to-market gains from its insurance unit. We raise our FY14 net profit forecast by 6% on a lower credit cost assumption, and lift our FV to SGD10.90 (from SGD10.60), on rolling forward our valuations. Maintain NEUTRAL.
- Stronger 3QFY13 results. OCBC's 3QFY13 net profit of SGD759m (+5% y-o-y, ex-divestment gains; +27% q-o-q) was in line with our and consensus expectations, with its 9MFY13 net profit of SGD2.05bn (-5% y-o-y, based on core 9MFY12 net profit) accounting for 76.5-77.5% of our and consensus full-year estimates.
- Rebound led by insurance unit. The strong q-o-q rebound in group net profit was mainly due to stronger contribution from Great Eastern (GE) as a result of unrealised mark-to-market (MTM) gains in GE's nonparticipating fund. Consequently, GE's net profit contribution to the group surged to SGD235m from SGD4m in 2QFY13. Ex-GE contribution, 3QFY13's core net profit of SGD524m slipped 12% q-o-q and 8% y-o-y, mainly weighed down by weaker non-interest income (-11% q-o-q; -7% y-o-y) and higher loan allowances (+13% q-o-q; +34% y-o-y).
- Outlook. OCBC has guided for 2014 loan growth of a high single digit. We believe the slower growth guided (vis-à-vis 2013) is partly in response to the various property cooling measures imposed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS). Already, OCBC is seeing a 30% y-o-y drop in residential mortgage applications and thinks that the impact on loan growth would start to be felt in 2H2014. The group remains open for potential M&A activities, especially if these involve any of OCBC's four key markets of Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia and Greater China.
- Forecasts. Our FY13 earnings forecasts are unchanged but we raise our FY14 net profit forecast by 6% on revising down loan allowances.
- Investment case. We lift our FV to SGD10.90 (from SGD10.60) after rolling forward our valuation base year to end-2014 (from June 2014). There is no change to our target P/BV multiple of 1.45x. The pickup in OCBC's profitability was largely due to MTM gains from the insurance unit, while the underlying profit at its banking operations was more muted. Maintain NEUTRAL.
3QFY13 results review
OCBC's 3QFY13 net profit of SGD759m (+5% y-o-y, ex-divestment gains; +27% q-oq) was in line with our and consensus expectations, with the 9MFY13 net profit of SGD2.05bn (-5% y-o-y, based on 9MFY12 core net profit) accounting for 76.5-77.5% of our and consensus full-year estimates. 3QFY13 net interest income grew by a decent 4% y-o-y and 2% q-o-q, underpinned by a loan expansion of 16% y-o-y/2% q-o-q. NIM was broadly stable q-o-q at 1.63% (-1bp q-o-q) but down 12bps y-o-y, which OCBC attributed to the low interest rate environment and dilution from lower-yielding mortgages.
The group's 3QFY13 non-interest income rebounded 29% q-o-q (+3% y-o-y) mainly on higher contribution from life assurance (SGD240m vs. 2QFY13: SGD16m, 3QFY12: SGD190m). GE's non-participating fund benefited from MTM gains following the US Fed's decision to delay QE tapering. The 3QFY13 fee income of SGD352m (+1% q-o-q; +16% y-o-y) was a new quarterly high for OCBC, but trading income slid 48% q-o-q/68% y-o-y given the tougher market conditions. Overall, noninterest income contribution improved q-o-q to 44.3% from 38.7% in 2QFY13 (3QFY12: 44.4%).
Overheads for the quarter were well-contained (-5% q-o-q; -1% y-o-y), resulting in the cost-to-income ratio (CIR) declining to 38.8% (3QFY12: 40.3%; 2QFY13: 45.8%). The q-o-q drop in overheads was due to a combination of lower staff incentive-related costs and lower insurance-related expenses, while the y-o-y drop was a result of lower insurance-related costs. Loan allowances trended higher in 3QFY13 (SGD94m vs 2QFY13: SGD83m; 3QFY12: SGD70m). The q-o-q rise mainly stemmed from higher specific allowances for the ex-Singapore and Malaysia portfolio, but portfolio allowances were lower due to a slowdown in loan growth. Y-o-y, the rise was due to both higher specific and portfolio allowances. Specific allowance charge-off rate (annualised) stood at 10bps (3QFY12: 7bps; 2QFY13: 3bps).
As expected, loan growth momentum eased to +2% q-o-q (+16% y-o-y) vs +7% q-o-q (+15% y-o-y) in 2QFY13. With annualised growth at 16.5%, OCBC appears likely to end the year ahead of the high-single digit to low double-digit growth guided earlier. The q-o-q growth was led by trade and housing loans, but corporate lending in Singapore softened.
Meanwhile, total customer deposits expanded by a quicker 3% q-o-q pace (+15% yo-y), led by fixed and other deposits , but current account and savings account (CASA) deposits grew by a slower 1% q-o-q pace (+20% y-o-y). This resulted in the group's loan-to-deposit ratio (LDR) dipping q-o-q to 88.4% from 89% at end-2QFY13, while CASA ratio eased to 49.3% from 50.1% at end-June 2013. The quarter also saw OCBC build up USD liquidity given the strong demand for trade financing. USD deposits jumped 10% q-o-q (+48% y-o-y), resulting in the USD LDR falling to 110% from 116% a quarter ago. Meanwhile, SGD LDR eased slightly to 83.9% from 84.5% at end-June 2013.
Absolute gross non-performing loans (NPLs) rose 14% q-o-q and 12% y-o-y, resulting in an uptick in gross NPL ratio to 0.8% from 0.7% at end-2QFY13 (end-3QFY12: 0.84%). The rise in absolute gross NPL was largely from Greater China and Malaysia, and was related to the manufacturing and transportation sectors. There was also a slight increase in housing loan delinquency. Not surprisingly, a considerable portion of the briefing focused on asset quality. However, management did not appear overly-concerned with the rise in absolute gross NPL as asset quality, while coming off at exceptionally low levels, generally remained benign. OCBC also guided for normalised gross NPL ratios of around 0.9-1%. Cumulative allowances stood at 130% of total non-performing assets (NPAs), down slightly from 144% as at 30 June 2013.
Finally, OCBC disclosed that its Basel III CET-1/Tier 1/total capital ratios stood at 14.3%/14.3%/16.1% respectively as at end-Sept 2013, down about 60-70bps from the end-June 2013 level due to redemption of its SGD1bn preference shares in July 2013.
Other briefing highlights
For 2014, OCBC is guiding for loan growth of high single digit. We believe this slower growth guidance vis-à-vis 2013 is partly in response to the various property cooling measures introduced by the MAS. Already, OCBC has seen a 30% y-o-y drop in residential mortgage applications and thinks that the impact on loan growth would start to be felt in 2H2014. Management sees some pressure on funding cost (mainly fixed deposits) but said that the banking group will still benefit when interest rates start to rise due to its high CASA proportion.
OCBC remains open to potential M&A activities, especially if these involve any of the group's four key markets of Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia and Greater China. As Hong Kong fits in with its Greater China strategy, the group will expand its operations there. This unit currently focuses on corporate banking and retail banking via Bank of Singapore.
Risks
The risks include: i) slower-than-expected loans growth, ii) weaker-than-expected NIMs, iii) weaker-than-expected capital market activities, iv) a deterioration in asset quality, and v) adverse impact from rising bond yields on its securities portfolio.
Forecasts
We keep our FY13 earnings forecasts unchanged. However, with credit cost still low, albeit on a rising trend, we believe our previous FY14 overall credit cost assumption of 34bps was too conservative. We cut this to 21bps, which accordingly lifts our FY14 net profit forecast by 6%.
Valuation and recommendation
We raise our FV to SGD10.90 from SGD10.60 after rolling forward our valuation base year to end-2014 (previously June 2014). There is no change to our target P/BV multiple of 1.45x. The OCBC's stronger profitability was largely due to MTM gains from the insurance unit, while the underlying profitability of its banking operations was more muted. We continue to expect earnings volatility at the insurance unit given that the QE tapering is just a matter of time. Also, as we deem the stock's valuation not as attractive as its peers', we maintain our Neutral call.
Company Profile
OCBC is the third-largest Singapore bank by loan size. Besides Singapore, it has significant operations in Malaysia and Indonesia.
Recommendation Chart