Broadway reported a set of disappointing 4QFY12 results with a core PATMI loss of SGD7.6m on the back of SGD150.2m revenue (+31.9% YoY). For the full year FY12, taking off the exceptional items such as forex gain and insurance claim, the company would have lost SGD5.7m, which is worse than our initial expectation of SGD4.1m. Going forward, we reiterate our view that the industry outlook for hard disk drives (HDD) is extremely challenging and that group has not scaled down fast enough to cater to the shrinking orders. While the foam business may help to offset the woes, it is not enough to save the group from reporting losses in 1H13. Maintain SELL, with an unchanged TP of S$0.265 based on 0.5x FY12 P/B (-1 S.D. 5-yr historical) which the counter was trading at late last year.
Headline numbers look good. Boosted up by the one-off insurance claims from the Thai flood incident as well as mark-to-market forex gain as a result of the strengthening of the SGD, Broadway posts a good headline net profit of SGD24.5m. However, the underlying operational performance is poor, with a SGD5.7m core PATMI loss.
HDD business is the culprit. During the year, the group ramped up its HDD production capacity during 1H in anticipation of a strong 2H. As the outcome indicated otherwise, the group incurred huge manufacturing overheads amidst poor factory utilisation rate, resulting in net operating loss of SGD10.8m for its HDD business alone.
Outlook remains challenging. Going forward, it is widely expected by the industry that HDD will continue its structural decline in the face of poor PC outlook and threats of solid state drive substitution. We continue to believe that the group has not downsized its HDD business fast enough to cater for this downturn. As such, though we acknowledge that its foam business may continue to grow strong and its semicon business may recover back to profitability, it is not enough to prop up the loss of the HDD business which represent 65% of the group's FY12 revenue.
No final dividends. In view of the challenging business conditions, Broadway decided to scrap the final dividends for the first time since 2006.