FJB reported PATMI decline of 72% YoY, to SGD1.3m in 2QFY13. Revenue fell 12% YoY to SGD96.9m, as sales across all segments fell. The results were below expectations. Its Timepiece segment recorded the deepest decline, largely due to fewer purchases by the Chinese in China and Hong Kong. The decline in sales from its North Asia market appears to have bottomed out, as management is starting to see some pick up in business. Given the weaker-than-expected 2Q results and the challenging outlook for the next 2 quarters, we have lowered our FY13 earnings estimate to SGD9.7m (from SGD14.6m). FJB's sound inventory management has allowed it to maintain its gross margins during past economic slowdowns, and this quarter is no different. Our DCF-based TP is subsequently lowered to SGD0.36, translating into a 12.5% upside. Maintain BUY
Decline in sales from Timepieces segment drags down profitability. The slowdown in the sales of luxury timepieces in 1QFY13 continued into the second quarter. On top of that, the global economic slowdown resulted in lower overall consumer spending, even during the festive season. Hence, even though 2Q is the seasonally stronger quarter, FJB recorded a YoY decline in PATMI. Management indicated that business in North Asia is picking up, as China's economy continues to improve.
Improves gross margins despite challenging business environment. Over the past seven years, FJB has always maintained gross profit margins of above 40% (except during the Global Financial Crisis when margin was 39.6%). This time is no different. For 2QFY13, FJB improved its gross margins, from 41.9% a year ago, to 42.8%. This reflects its successful management of its inventory. Despite the slower overall sales, management highlighted that there was no need for any write-offs or mark down of its inventory.
Lower our earnings estimates and TP. We are lowering our FY13 earnings estimates to SGD9.7m (from SGD14.6m), taking into consideration the challenging environment in the next few quarters. While sales in North Asia are showing signs of improvement, we are of the view that it may take a couple of quarters to revert to previous levels. As a result of the lower earnings estimate, our DCF-based TP has been lowered to SGD0.36 (from SGD0.39), a 12.5% upside from current levels.
Potential for Indonesia market to continue to do well. Management remains optimistic of its Indonesia market, supported by a growing middle- to high-income consumer group. Management highlighted that business volume at its Indonesian associate is higher. It has launched the VNC label in Indonesia and it was well-received.
Raoul continues to grow and progress well. FJB widened its Raoul distribution network as it now has more points of sale across the US and Europe. Through the last few years, FJB was able to raise Raoul's brand value and expand the business. It does not rule out the possibility of establishing another Raoul franchise outlet in one of its key markets. Although Raoul does not contribute significantly to Group revenue yet, should it open up more franchise outlets, it would be a reflection of the value of the Raoul brand that consumers and retailers hold.