Simons Trading Research

Author: simonsg   |   Latest post: Thu, 14 Nov 2019, 5:02 PM


StarHub - Earnings Rebound Likely to be Delayed

Author:   |    Publish date:

  • StarHub’s 4Q18 underlying earnings were 10% below our estimates. 
  • Cyber security business and digital transformation efforts may offset cost savings from other operations. 
  • FY19F dividend yield of 4.9% not appealing enough to await earnings recovery in FY20F.
  • Downgrade to HOLD with a revised Target Price of S$1.92

Earnings Rebound Delayed While 4.9% Dividend Yield Is Less Appealing Than Its Peers

  • STARHUB LTD (SGX:CC3)’s staff cost savings are likely to offset by
    1. expansion efforts of Ensign as StarHub scales up its cyber security operations and
    2. digital transformation efforts.
  • We cut FY19F/20F earnings by 8%/11%. The new dividend policy of 2.25Scts per quarter or 80% earnings payout ratio in FY19F, whichever is higher, might translate into 4.9% dividend yield (vs our 5.5% expectations) not appealing enough to await earnings recovery in FY20F.
  • NETLINK NBN TRUST (SGX:CJLU)’s 6.3% yield and SINGTEL (SGX:Z74)’s 5.7% yield are more attractive coupled with their superior earnings trajectory.

Where We Differ

  • We were over-optimistic on StarHub’s cost transformation efforts earlier. Now we are inline with consensus on FY19F earnings but our FY20F earnings are still higher than consensus on the back of shut-down of its co-axial network.

Potential Catalysts

  • Any network issues at TPG or weaker than anticipated uptake of TPG’s mobile plans could boost StarHub’s share price.


  • Downgrade to HOLD on a slower than expected recovery.
  • We cut our DCF-based Target Price to S$1.92 (WACC of 7%, Terminal growth of 0%) from S$2.45 earlier as we revise down our FY19/20F earnings projections by 8%/11% on a slower than expected recovery.

Key Risks to Our View

  • Bear case valuation is S$1.50 if TPG causes severe disruption.
  • StarHub could see a 2% drop in FY19F EBITDA under this enario vs our base case.

What's New - Earnings Rebound Likely to be Delayed

Underlying earnings of S$42m (-19% y-o-y, -26% q-o-q) was below our expectations of S$47m.

  • Cost of equipment sold dipped 11% y-o-y primarily due to the on-going migration of postpaid subscriber base to SIM-Only plans and lower volume of premium handsets sold. Cost of services also declined 6% y-o-y with StarHub’s on-going efforts to cut content costs as part of the restructuring of StarHub’s pay-TV business.
  • Marketing expenses climbed up on the back of accelerating fibre migrations, bringing EBITDA to S$ 111m (-22% y-o-y, - 25% q-o-q). Excluding one-off adjustments of S$26m pertaining to postpaid mobile revenue and adjustments to an onerous contract, StarHub reported an underlying EBITDA of S$137m in 4Q18.
  • Faced with higher overheads and shrinking profits, in 3Q18 StarHub announced cost-cutting measures aimed at achieving S$210m in cost savings over a three-year period starting from 4Q18 onwards. However, these costs savings failed to materalise in 4Q18 as StarHub reinvested part of these savings to expand its cyber-security venture, resulting in staff expenses growing by 11% y-o-y.
  • Depreciation and amortisation expenses for the quarter edged up 14% y-o-y (13% q-o-q) largely owing to the adoption of SFRS 16, which requires the capitalisation of certain operating lease assets of StarHub. Accordingly, StarHub reported an underlying net profit of S$42m (-19% y-o-y).

Variable dividend policy from FY19.

  • StarHub is transitioning to a new dividend policy whereby the telco plans to pay a quarterly cash dividend of ~2.25 Scts per share for FY19F, guaranteeing 9 Scts per share, down from the current 16Scts annual dividend. With this, StarHub is switching from a fixed to a variable dividend policy from FY19F and plans to distribute at least 80% of net profit each year.
  • The management has indicated that any payment above 9 Scts to be in line with the new dividend policy would occur in the last quarterly payment for the year.

4Q18 service revenue of S$457m (-7% y-o-y, flat q-o-q) was below our expectations.

  • StarHub reported 4Q18 mobile service revenue adjusted for one-offs of S$ 208.6m (-7% y-o-y, -2% q-o-q) driven by growing uptake of SIM-Only plans, and lower data add-ons, IDD and voice usage. The one-off S$16.6m contribution pertains to a loyalty program for mobile customers.
  • StarHub’s post-paid mobile ARPU fell S$3 q-o-q to S$41 in 4Q18 with the launch of cheaper SIM-Only plans with bigger data bundles issued towards the end of the quarter.
  • Revenues from Pay TV services dipped 4% q-o-q (-19% y-o-y) with the loss of ~14,000 subscribers, marginally below the previous quarter’s loss of ~15,000 subscribers. Enterprise segment proved to the only resilient business segment and continued on its growth momentum.

A look at Company's listed history – what drives StarHub’s share price? 

  • Refer to Appendix A in the PDF report attached. 

Outlook for 19/20F

StarHub to capitalise some opex with the adoption of SFRS 16.

  • Adoption of SFRS 16 will result in some operating leases being capitalised as right-of-use (ROU) assets leading to higher depreciation and amortisation charges from FY19F onwards. This should result in StarHub’s opex relating to operating leases edging down while D&A attributable to the capitalised leases will drive D&A expenses higher.
  • While this should result in a favorable improvement in EBITDA, it is unlikely to trickle down to benefit StarHub’s earnings due to higher D&A.

Migration to fibre and accelerated depreciation of the HFC network to weigh on FY19.

  • In November 2018, StarHub announced plans to cease providing broadband and Pay-TV services using its Hybrid Fibre Coaxial (HFC) Network by June 2019, ahead of the earlier proposed date of disconnection in 2020.
  • We expect to see a sharp rise in StarHub’s cost of services in FY19F as migrations to NBN accelerate, partially offset by reduction in content costs with the on-going restructuring of StarHub’s Pay TV business. Accordingly, HFC Network will be fully depreciated by 1H19, placing a further burden on StarHub’s income statement in FY19F

Staff cost savings likely to be eroded by the expansion of Ensign.

  • In 3Q18, StarHub entered into a joint venture agreement with Certis Cisco, a wholly owned subsidiary of the Temasek Group, to pool the cybersecurity assets of StarHub and Certis to create Ensign, a pure-play cybersecurity service provider. While the combined operations were marginally profitable at the point of formation, 4Q18 turned into a loss-making quarter for the cybersecurity company which reported losses of S$12m.
  • Cyber security operations are heavily labour intensive. The S$30m staff cost savings that StarHub accrued is likely to be overridden by the expansion efforts of Ensign as StarHub scales-up cyber security operations.
  • After factoring the above cost escalations, we have revised down our FY19/20F net profit by 8%/11%.

Source: DBS Research - 15 Feb 2019

Share this
Labels: StarHub

Related Stocks

Chart Stock Name Last Change Volume 
StarHub 1.47 0.00 (0.00%)

  Be the first to like this.



Top 10 Active Counters
 Powermatic Data 2.850.00 
 NX09100W 190601 90.000.00 
 NY09100H 240901 109.9520.00 
 Tai Sin Electric 0.330.00 
 3Cnergy 0.0090.00 
 KLW 0.0020.00 
 AsiaMedic 0.0150.00 
 Fuji Offset 0.380.00 
 Hiap Seng^ 0.0240.00 
 DEKW 0.470.00 
Partners & Brokers